How we verify reports
Last updated: 30 September 2026
No report becomes a petition until a reviewer has checked it against this written standard. A petition is an allegation passed to the authority responsible for the officer, never a finding. The officer's right to a fair hearing is always respected.
1. Who reviews reports
- Reviewers are appointed in writing by PublicWatch. Each one agrees in writing to keep reports confidential and is trained on this standard.
- A reviewer must step aside from any report about an officer, hospital or reporter they have a personal, family, professional or financial connection with.
- Reviewers sign in with their own account, and every action they take is recorded.
2. What must be true before a petition is sent
- The report names a specific government hospital and a specific date, and is about official duty: attendance, duty hours, private practice during duty hours, or someone signing in for the officer. We do not act on complaints about clinical judgement, attitude or private life.
- The account is specific and consistent, and fits what is known about the hospital, such as its clinic days and hours.
- It is supported by at least one of: a photo whose capture time fits the account; another independent report; consistent answers to our follow-up questions; or other material, such as a private clinic notice showing hours that overlap duty hours.
- The officer is identified with reasonable certainty, or the petition says clearly that the name is not known.
- Nothing suggests malice or a personal dispute, and the petition contains nothing that could identify the reporter.
- The reviewer must confirm each of these points before the system allows a petition to be sent, and the confirmation is recorded.
3. Photographs
- Location (GPS), phone details and all other hidden data are removed from photos when they are received. Only the time the photo was taken is kept.
- Before a petition is sent, the reviewer opens every photo at full size. A photo that shows a patient, a staff member or anyone else who could be identified, a medical record or a screen is not attached to the petition. It stays only in our confidential file, where the retention periods below apply.
- Voice messages are never attached, because a voice can identify the reporter. If an inquiry needs one, we provide a written transcript.
4. Who receives a petition
- A petition goes only to the offices that can inquire into the matter under the Establishments Code: the head of the hospital, the Regional Director of Health Services and the Regional Dental Surgeon, with a copy to the Provincial Director of Health Services.
- The Ministry of Health or other national bodies receive a petition only where they are the responsible authority (for example, for line-ministry hospitals) or where the regional offices have not acted.
- Every petition is marked confidential, states that it is an unproven allegation, and asks that the officer be informed and given a full opportunity to respond before any finding is made.
5. The officer's right to respond
- We do not contact the officer before a petition is sent. Doing so could expose the reporter to retaliation and allow records to be changed. The officer's employer, which has the legal power to hold an inquiry and the duty to hear the officer, decides the facts, not PublicWatch.
- An officer who believes they are named in a petition can contact our data protection contact at any time. We will tell them what was alleged, without revealing who reported it.
- If the officer sends us a written response and asks us to, we will forward it to everyone who received the petition.
6. Corrections and withdrawals
- If we learn that a detail in a petition was wrong, or that a report was false, we send a correction or a withdrawal to everyone who received the petition, normally within 14 days, and ask them to place it on file.
- A report found to be knowingly false is closed, and it is never used again.
7. How long we keep information
- The reporter's optional contact details: deleted 12 months after the last activity on the report, or sooner on request.
- Reports closed as not verified: deleted completely, with their evidence, 6 months after closing.
- Reports never completed: deleted 12 months after the last activity.
- Verified or referred reports: 2 years after the last activity, the evidence, the officer's name and all descriptions are deleted. Only the hospital, district, type of concern and date are kept, for the public totals.
- These periods are applied automatically every day.
Data protection contact: [email protected]